This website uses cookies. Using this website means you are okay with this but you can find out more and learn how to manage your cookie choices here.
What's Onreview

Review: Winterreise, Barber Institute, University of Birmingham


Sir Thomas Allen

What a privilege for a packed house. Here we were listening to Sir Thomas Allen, one of the finest baritones in the world, accompanied by Joseph Middleton, a sensitive and truly talented young pianist, performing one of the young Schubert’s awesome song cycles: Die Winterreise.

Set to 24 poems by Willhelm Muller and described by Schubert as spine-­chilling – for any listener this was truly thought provoking, with dark emotions being revealed throughout.

One wonders how many performances of this work Sir Thomas Allen has presented? What a joy to hear his fresh, flawless voice at every dynamic.

Never a waver with clear German text, matching easily with programme translations alongside for captivated listeners. There was minimum but relevant communication throughout. There was a discreet step forward for added drama, including subtle hand movements with a distinct conviction that this was a story being told to each individual in the venue.

Middleton discreetly joined forces with lovely phrasing and imaginative, but never overwhelming collaborations. His breathless pianissimos are a joy; achingly sad minor passages contrasting with brief flashes of caressing major sunlight. There was splendid clarity for The Post Coach (but, alas, no letter); more ferocity for a brief storm then a heart-­stopping velvety long introduction for a“pitiless tavern”. One wonders what sorrows dear Schubert was experiencing during this period of his short life.

A recital to treasure.

View full mobile page